Best Mattress for Back Pain: What Should You Look For?
If you wake up with a stiff or aching back, one of the first questions you may ask is: “Do I need a new mattress?”
Sometimes the answer is yes. But buying the most expensive mattress—or simply buying the firmest mattress in the store—isn’t necessarily the answer.
The goal is to find a mattress that provides enough support to keep your spine in a comfortable position while still providing enough cushioning for your shoulders, hips, and other pressure points.
Here are some things I recommend looking at before buying a new mattress.
1. Don't Automatically Buy the Firmest Mattress
For years, people with back problems were often told, “You need a really firm mattress.”
That isn't necessarily true.
A mattress that is too firm may create excessive pressure around the shoulders and hips, especially for side sleepers. A mattress that is too soft may allow the hips and pelvis to sink too far.
For many people, medium-firm is a good place to start, but there is no single firmness level that is right for everyone.
Your body size, sleeping position, existing problems, and personal comfort all matter.
2. Look for Support AND Pressure Relief
These are two different things.
Support helps prevent excessive sinking and keeps your body from collapsing into the mattress.
Pressure relief allows areas such as your shoulders and hips to settle comfortably into the surface.
A good mattress should give you a combination of both.
If you're lying on your back, you shouldn't feel like your hips are sinking dramatically below the rest of your body.
If you're lying on your side, your shoulder and hip should be able to sink slightly without feeling excessive pressure.
3. Consider Your Sleeping Position
Side Sleepers
Side sleepers generally need more cushioning around the shoulders and hips. An extremely firm mattress can sometimes create uncomfortable pressure in these areas.
Look for something supportive with enough cushioning to allow the shoulder and hip to settle slightly.
Back Sleepers
Back sleepers generally need good support through the pelvis and lower back.
If the mattress is too soft and the pelvis sinks excessively, it may leave you waking up stiff or uncomfortable.
Stomach Sleepers
Stomach sleepers often need a somewhat firmer sleeping surface because excessive sinking through the midsection can place the low back in an uncomfortable position.
4. Don't Get Too Hung Up on Mattress Type
There are plenty of choices today:
Memory foam
Traditional innerspring
Hybrid
Latex
Adjustable-air mattresses
I wouldn't choose a mattress based solely on the material.
A well-designed hybrid mattress may work wonderfully for one person and poorly for another. The same is true of memory foam, latex, or traditional innerspring mattresses.
Instead, focus on how well the mattress supports YOUR body.
5. Look for a Good In-Home Trial
This is one of the most important things I would look for.
Lying on a mattress in a showroom for five minutes isn't the same as sleeping on it for several weeks.
Many mattress companies now offer sleep trials around 90–120 nights, although policies vary considerably. Some companies also require you to keep the mattress for a minimum break-in period before allowing a return.
Before you buy, ask:
How long is the trial period?
Is there a required break-in period?
Is the mattress completely refundable?
Who pays for return shipping or pickup?
Are there restocking or transportation fees?
Does buying from a third-party retailer change the return policy?
Read the actual return policy rather than relying only on what the salesperson tells you.
6. Check the Warranty Carefully
A long warranty sounds impressive, but the details matter more than the number printed on the advertisement.
Many warranties cover things such as manufacturing defects, broken components, or excessive permanent indentations. They generally don't cover normal wear, comfort preferences, or damage caused by improper use.
Some warranties may also require you to use a certain type of foundation or bed frame.
I would generally look for a mattress with at least a 10-year warranty and then read exactly what that warranty covers.
Pay particular attention to the company's definition of sagging or body impressions.
A warranty may say it covers sagging—but only after the indentation reaches a specific depth.
That's an important detail.
7. Make Sure Your Foundation Is Appropriate
Sometimes the mattress gets blamed when the problem is actually underneath it.
Check your:
Box spring
Foundation
Platform
Bed frame
Center support
Slats
A worn-out or poorly supported foundation can affect how even a good mattress feels.
It can also potentially affect the mattress warranty, so check the manufacturer's requirements.
8. Don't Assume More Expensive Means Better
You can spend several thousand dollars on a mattress, but price alone doesn't guarantee that it will be the right mattress for your back.
I'd rather see someone spend money on a mattress that fits their body, sleep position, and comfort needs than buy the most expensive mattress simply because it has impressive marketing.
9. Give Your Body Some Time to Adjust
Don't judge a new mattress after one night.
Your old mattress may have gradually changed over many years, and your body has adapted to it.
A different sleeping surface can feel strange initially.
This is another reason a good home trial is so important.
Unless the mattress is clearly causing significant discomfort, give yourself some time to determine whether it's actually a better fit.
10. Remember: Your Mattress May Not Be the Whole Problem
This is probably the biggest point.
If your back consistently bothers you when you wake up, your mattress certainly deserves consideration—but don't automatically assume the mattress is the cause.
Joint mobility, previous injuries, muscle tightness, activity levels, sleeping position, prolonged sitting, and other factors may also contribute.
If you're replacing mattresses repeatedly and your back still isn't improving, it may be time to look at the problem differently.
That's something I see frequently in practice.
Rather than simply chasing the symptom, I want to determine why the problem keeps coming back and what may be contributing to it.
If you've been dealing with a stubborn back problem that hasn't responded the way you expected, I'd be happy to take a look and determine whether conservative care may be an appropriate option.
Dr. Scott Stiffey
Pro Active Chiropractic Center,
Palmyra, Missouri
Comments